NYC DSA proud socialist
Memo
Published November 5, 2025

Ten Reasons Why Mamdani Politics Won’t Win Outside of NYC

We congratulate Mayor-elect Mamdani on his win and wish him well in office. But because Mamdani is a national figure drawing enormous attention, Democrats in districts and states not awash in blue will be forced to answer for him, and many commentators are concluding that his win can serve as a model for how Democrats should run in competitive races. We urge Democrats at all levels to resist the pressure to align with Mamdani’s politics and agenda, and we offer ten key points to make to interest groups, donors, and activists about why doing so will fail in tough races.

Photo of Third Way
Third Way
What is our Vision?

About Third Way

We are fighting for opportunity, so everyone has the chance to earn a good life; progress on social issues, so all have the freedom to live the lives they choose; and security, so we are protected from 21st century global threats.

Learn More

Subscribe

Get updates whenever new content is added. We'll never share your email with anyone.


On X